Butcher Burger - Westfield, NJ (November 16, 2016)

Variety of burger selections

Rating..........................6.76

 

Flavor...........................................6.94

Beef Quality.................................7.11

Freshness......................................6.44

Uniqueness..................................6.56

Aesthetics.....................................6.83

Structural Integrity.....................6.50

Burger-to-Bun Ratio..................6.67

Grease Factor..............................6.78



Additional Comments:

 

"No need for sweet toppings on a savory dish. Too much goop had the large bun sliding all over the place. Shame too, because I love truffle mayo. Other than the cool meat which should have been Medium - it was a particularly adequate, pretentious, overpriced burger." - The Jackal

​

"English muffin needed a little toasting and texture." - Anonymous

​

"Had a bun so stale I was afraid I would break a tooth eating it. Even so I persevered. Burger needed more seasoning. Not overly greasy which was a plus."  - Fahrvegnugen

​

"The Butcher Burger was very tasty. Caramelized onions was a perfect complement." - Anonymous

​

"Overall good burger but the pretzel bun wasn't as good as I hoped. I'd eat here again but don't need to rush back." - Bress

​

"My bun was a little burned, but the rest of the burger was top notch. One thing that was mentioned a lot is that the burgers came out rare. I feel like that actually helped the flavor but I know many were turned off. There was a sweet taste to the pretzel bun (or whatever it was called) that I really liked. Apps were tiny little portions but were good. Service was great. I thought they handled our large group really well. I had a bacon cheeseburger. I look forward to coming back and trying some others!" - Rads

​

"A little disappointed on flavor. Good ambience." - The Hoff

​

"Bacon Cheeseburger - quite tasty with just the right amount of crispy bacon. Pretzel bun was interesting, but a bit dry. Burger actually got better as eaten. Great integrity. Truffle fries were yummy." - G.G.

​

"Classy burger, better than the early reviews had suggested." - A.A.