Winberies - Summit, NJ (May 18, 2016)

Shitake Truffle Prime Burger, Hickory Burger, Bistro Burger, or Southern Belle Burger

Rating..........................6.63

 

Flavor...........................................6.74

Beef Quality.................................6.89

Freshness......................................6.79

Uniqueness..................................6.21

Aesthetics.....................................6.00

Structural Integrity.....................6.84

Burger-to-Bun Ratio..................6.74

Grease Factor..............................6.32



Additional Comments:

 

"Southern Belle rang all of my bells.  Sharp flavor, compelling combination." - A.A.

 

"Solid Burger!  First Southern Belle I've tamed.  Crispy roll and perfect burger to bun ratio." - Dr. G.

 

"It hurts me to say this but my burger was cold, killing the burger experience.  To add insult to injury, the fries were equally as cold.  I've been here multiple times and liked it, the scores would have been even lower but I know it's a good place.  Obviously, they struggled with a large party.  At least put the burger under a heat lamp.  Disappointing." - Fahrvegnugen

 

"Not memorable but pretty good.  Thick patty, mushrooms were fresh, and it hung together pretty well.  It was above average." -Belosa

 

"Solid Southern Belle Burger.  Would have liked more waffle fries and some cole slaw." - Bressler

 

"Not only did I have to wait too long for this cold, tasteless hockey puck, but it was among the biggest wastes of my time in all of Burger Club." - The Jackal

 

"Luke warm!" - Bowling

 

"Cold bun and meat." - Schultz

 

"Just an ordinary burger...we said it was like something I make in my backyard." - Espo

 

"Burger was colder than my beer." - Swafay

 

"Other than being completely overcooked and cold, it was pretty good." - Plotty

 

"Goodness - somebody needs to teach them how to serve food hot.  The first bite was dry.  Way too much bun that crumbled and flaked - it didn't compliment the burger." - No Business

 

"Great burger, but not cooked medium as ordered." - Anonymous

 

"Bistro Burger was good, but cold." - Villaverde

 

"They did well.  Huge burger and bread/beef ingredients were top notch.  Nothing was special with the flavor despite some special sauces added.  I would like to come back and try another." - E Rads

 

"Good looking burger, good taste - bun could be fresher." - Siegel

 

"The Bistro Burger looked great but the bun wasn't fresh and the beef somehow lacked flavor.  I enjoyed it but couldn't help but think this was more beauty over substance." - Chief

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Winberies Burger 1

Winberies Burger 1

Winberies Burger 2

Winberies Burger 2

Winberies

Winberies